I am a fan of the Hogue grips and have used them on a few different hand guns. For some reason though, I personally didn't like the fit of the Hogue on my Shield Plus. I think it had to do with the grip being really small for the Shield compared to their other grips, and the finger grooves made it harder for me to feel like I was getting a firm grip. In all fairness, I didn't try the Shield 45 version which may work better for you.
I did recently buy the Talon Grip Pro grip texture for my P365xl (which also has a very skinny grip feel), and that has been a game changer for me. They sell the grips in rubber or granulate textures as well, but the pro texture mixes both the rubber and granulate styles together to make this incredible feeling grip (in my opinion of course)
TALON Grips are stick-on gun grips that help you get a secure hold on your firearm improving performance, safety, and confidence so you maintain control.
talongungrips.com